Dear Authors,

All points raised by the referees have been adequately adressed in your replies. Please revise your manuscript as proposed before resubmission.

Yours sincerely,
Uwe Ehret

Dear Authors,

I have read your replies to the comments of the referees and to the short comment by Ed Sudiky, which was provided after the end of the open discussion phase. In order to promote open discussion, we had decided to re-open the discussion phase to handle the short comment as usual.

Your replies to the referees and the short comment were satisfactory, so please proceed now as follows:
- Submit a single file with all replies to the referees and to the short comment.
- Submit a revised version of the manuscript with changes from the initial mansucript highlighted. This will facilitate the re-evaluation.
- I will then ask the referees to evaluate your revised work before making the final decision.

Yours sincerely,
Uwe Ehret

Dear Authors,

Both referees have acknowledged your efforts in adressing their comments. Referee #1 has suggested further changes (see attached report). It is meant in a constructive manner to make your manuscript even more citeable. So may I ask you to provide a reply and a revised manuscript.

Yours sincerely,
Uwe Ehret

Dear Authors,

No more points for revision after the last round of reviewing. Your're done. Congratulations on a good paper.

Yours sincerely,
Uwe Ehret