The three reviews offer detailed points that require very serious consideration, with appropriate clarifications in a revised manuscript.
The authors' responses appear well thought out and convincing, and a revised manuscript reflecting the additional information and clarifications can, I believe, fully address the reviews. Please proceed with a thorough revision.
To summarize: Thorough and thoughtful revision is required, followed by careful review of a revised manuscript.

Comments to the Author:
The three reviews offered highly detailed and constructive comments, which required serious consideration and thorough explanations and clarifications in a revised manuscript.
The authors' responses are similarly highly detailed, well thought out and convincing, and the manuscript has been revised to address each and every review comment.
Given the explanations in the author responses, and the correspondingly thorough revisions to the manuscript, which I reviewed carefully, I am satisfied that at least the vast majority of the review comments have been addressed fully and satisfactorily. As such, I see no need for additional review and am happy to recommend publication in HESS.