This is a very interesting paper, in that several methods were applied in an attempt to close the water balance whereas many such studies are focused on one part of the hydrological cycle. Although the paper is limited by the relatively short time period of the study, it does provide additional information for studies in this region (and perhaps other cloud forest regions) where hydrological studies which consider the full water balance are lacking. Overall, a sound contribution which may prove to be a very important paper in time to come.

The editorial task has been aided by the initial submission of a very well written paper, two excellent reviewers (Dr Mark Gush and Prof Sampurno Bruijnzeel) who responded rapidly and with very useful and insightful comments, and finally a well considered response from the authors.

The paper can now be accepted subject to the author's proposed amendments being made in the final submission. Please go ahead and submit the revised paper.