Preprints
https://doi.org/10.5194/hess-2018-187
© Author(s) 2018. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
https://doi.org/10.5194/hess-2018-187
© Author(s) 2018. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
15 May 2018
| 15 May 2018
Status: this discussion paper is a preprint. It has been under review for the journal Hydrology and Earth System Sciences (HESS). The manuscript was not accepted for further review after discussion. Please read the editorial note.
Comment: Getting the Methodology Wrong for Analysing the Hydrological Changes in Watersheds
Abstract. This article is a critique on the paper Spatial characterization of long-term hydrological change in the Arkavathy watershed adjacent to Bangalore, India
, by Penny et al. (2018), published in the journal of Hydrology and Earth System Sciences (volume 22, issue number 1). The article highlights choice of inappropriate methodology and faulty assumptions by the authors for analysing the watershed scale hydrological changes, generating misleading results and inferences.
Please read the editorial note first before accessing the preprint.
How to cite. Bassi, N., Kumara, B. K. H., Sahasranaman, M., and Ganguly, A.: Comment: Getting the Methodology Wrong for Analysing the Hydrological Changes in Watersheds, Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci. Discuss. [preprint], https://doi.org/10.5194/hess-2018-187, 2018.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
Download & links
-
Please read the editorial note first before accessing the preprint.
-
Preprint
(489 KB)
Download & links
-
Please read the editorial note first before accessing the preprint.
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC: Author comment | RC: Referee comment | SC: Short comment | EC: Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
-
SC1: 'Reply to Comment: Getting the Methodology Wrong for Analysing the Hydrological Changes in Watersheds', Joshua Peschel, 16 May 2018
-
AC1: 'J. Peschel', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC1: 'J. Peschel', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
SC2: 'Manuscript which criticises a published paper', Ross Woods, 16 May 2018
-
AC2: 'Response to R.A. Woods', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC2: 'Response to R.A. Woods', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
SC3: 'Criticisms off the mark', Ciaran Harman, 17 May 2018
-
SC9: 'Reply to comment by C Harman on behalf of the authors', Meera Sahasranaman, 18 May 2018
-
SC9: 'Reply to comment by C Harman on behalf of the authors', Meera Sahasranaman, 18 May 2018
-
SC4: 'HESS Policy on Criticisms', Hilary McMillan, 18 May 2018
-
AC3: 'Response to H. McMillan', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC3: 'Response to H. McMillan', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
SC5: 'Spatial scale not consistent', Gabrielle Boisrame, 18 May 2018
-
AC4: 'Response to G. Boisrame', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC4: 'Response to G. Boisrame', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
SC6: 'Comment violates Hess policy', Nandita Basu, 18 May 2018
-
AC5: 'Response to Nandita Basu', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC5: 'Response to Nandita Basu', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
SC7: 'Abuse of HESS as an open access journal', Murugesu Sivapalan, 18 May 2018
-
AC6: 'Response to M. Sivapalan', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC6: 'Response to M. Sivapalan', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
SC8: 'Comment does not substantively continue the discussion beyond interactive discussion period', Alejandro Flores, 18 May 2018
-
AC7: 'Reply to A.N. Flores', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC7: 'Reply to A.N. Flores', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
EC1: 'Editorial Note', Erwin Zehe, 04 Jun 2018
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC: Author comment | RC: Referee comment | SC: Short comment | EC: Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
-
SC1: 'Reply to Comment: Getting the Methodology Wrong for Analysing the Hydrological Changes in Watersheds', Joshua Peschel, 16 May 2018
-
AC1: 'J. Peschel', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC1: 'J. Peschel', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
SC2: 'Manuscript which criticises a published paper', Ross Woods, 16 May 2018
-
AC2: 'Response to R.A. Woods', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC2: 'Response to R.A. Woods', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
SC3: 'Criticisms off the mark', Ciaran Harman, 17 May 2018
-
SC9: 'Reply to comment by C Harman on behalf of the authors', Meera Sahasranaman, 18 May 2018
-
SC9: 'Reply to comment by C Harman on behalf of the authors', Meera Sahasranaman, 18 May 2018
-
SC4: 'HESS Policy on Criticisms', Hilary McMillan, 18 May 2018
-
AC3: 'Response to H. McMillan', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC3: 'Response to H. McMillan', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
SC5: 'Spatial scale not consistent', Gabrielle Boisrame, 18 May 2018
-
AC4: 'Response to G. Boisrame', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC4: 'Response to G. Boisrame', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
SC6: 'Comment violates Hess policy', Nandita Basu, 18 May 2018
-
AC5: 'Response to Nandita Basu', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC5: 'Response to Nandita Basu', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
SC7: 'Abuse of HESS as an open access journal', Murugesu Sivapalan, 18 May 2018
-
AC6: 'Response to M. Sivapalan', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC6: 'Response to M. Sivapalan', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
SC8: 'Comment does not substantively continue the discussion beyond interactive discussion period', Alejandro Flores, 18 May 2018
-
AC7: 'Reply to A.N. Flores', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
AC7: 'Reply to A.N. Flores', Nitin Bassi, 21 May 2018
-
EC1: 'Editorial Note', Erwin Zehe, 04 Jun 2018
Viewed
Total article views: 5,075 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 15 May 2018)
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4,304 | 696 | 75 | 5,075 | 74 | 79 |
- HTML: 4,304
- PDF: 696
- XML: 75
- Total: 5,075
- BibTeX: 74
- EndNote: 79
Viewed (geographical distribution)
Total article views: 4,327 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
Thereof 4,218 with geography defined
and 109 with unknown origin.
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
1
Cited
1 citations as recorded by crossref.
Discussed
Latest update: 14 Dec 2024
Nitin Bassi
Institute for Resource Analysis and Policy, Liaison Office, Delhi-110085, India
B. K. Harish Kumara
Center for Education Environment and Community, Hassan-573130, Karnataka, India
Meera Sahasranaman
Institute for Resource Analysis and Policy, Head Office, Hyderabad-500082, India
Arijit Ganguly
Institute for Resource Analysis and Policy, Head Office, Hyderabad-500082, India
Download
Please read the editorial note first before accessing the preprint.
- Preprint
(489 KB) - Metadata XML