|
03 Apr 2013
Status : this preprint was under review for the journal HESS. A revision for further review has not been submitted.
Temporal stability of soil moisture patterns measured by proximal ground-penetrating radar
J. Minet , N. E. C. Verhoest , S. Lambot , and M. Vanclooster
We analyzed the temporal stability of soil moisture patterns acquired using a proximal ground-penetrating radar (GPR) in a 2.5 ha agricultural field at five different dates over three weeks. The GPR system was mounted on a mobile platform, allowing for real-time mapping of soil moisture with a high spatial resolution (2–5 m). The spatio-temporal soil moisture patterns were in accordance with the meteorological data and with soil moisture measurements from soil core sampling. Time-stable areas showing the field-average moisture could be revealed by two methods: (1) by the computation of temporal stability indicators based on relative differences of soil moisture to the field-average and (2) by the spatial intersection of the areas showing the field-average. Locations where the mean relative difference was below 0.02 m3 m−3 extended up to 10% of the field area whereas the intersection of areas showing the field-average within a tolerance of 0.02 m3 m−3 covered 5% of the field area. Compared to most of the previous studies about temporal stability of soil moisture, time-stable areas and their spatial patterns could be revealed instead of single point locations, owing to the advanced GPR method for real-time mapping. It is believed that determining spatially coherent time-stable areas is more informative rather than determining time-stable points. Other acquisitions over larger time periods would be necessary to assert the robustness of the time-stable areas.
Received: 26 Feb 2013 – Discussion started: 03 Apr 2013
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
J. Minet , N. E. C. Verhoest , S. Lambot , and M. Vanclooster
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
J. Minet , N. E. C. Verhoest , S. Lambot , and M. Vanclooster
J. Minet , N. E. C. Verhoest , S. Lambot , and M. Vanclooster
Viewed
Total article views: 2,568 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,636
815
117
2,568
145
162
HTML: 1,636
PDF: 815
XML: 117
Total: 2,568
BibTeX: 145
EndNote: 162
Views and downloads (calculated since 03 Apr 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Apr 2013
51
92
6
149
May 2013
22
38
4
64
Jun 2013
10
13
0
23
Jul 2013
12
15
0
27
Aug 2013
4
11
1
16
Sep 2013
10
10
0
20
Oct 2013
16
12
0
28
Nov 2013
13
15
0
28
Dec 2013
9
20
0
29
Jan 2014
8
16
0
24
Feb 2014
12
15
3
30
Mar 2014
7
11
2
20
Apr 2014
6
8
0
14
May 2014
7
0
7
Jun 2014
5
15
0
20
Jul 2014
3
9
0
12
Aug 2014
3
10
0
13
Sep 2014
5
9
0
14
Oct 2014
1
8
0
9
Nov 2014
10
18
0
28
Dec 2014
6
11
1
18
Jan 2015
10
9
1
20
Feb 2015
9
8
0
17
Mar 2015
14
8
1
23
Apr 2015
11
2
0
13
May 2015
1
2
0
3
Jun 2015
11
5
0
16
Jul 2015
13
10
2
25
Aug 2015
5
7
0
12
Sep 2015
7
4
0
11
Oct 2015
9
9
0
18
Nov 2015
8
5
0
13
Dec 2015
4
8
0
12
Jan 2016
14
8
0
22
Feb 2016
9
11
1
21
Mar 2016
10
8
0
18
Apr 2016
5
9
0
14
May 2016
4
4
0
8
Jun 2016
4
4
0
8
Jul 2016
4
2
1
7
Aug 2016
6
6
0
12
Sep 2016
4
0
4
Oct 2016
3
3
7
13
Nov 2016
3
1
8
12
Dec 2016
2
0
2
Jan 2017
8
2
0
10
Feb 2017
7
1
8
Mar 2017
17
5
0
22
Apr 2017
16
1
2
19
May 2017
18
1
2
21
Jun 2017
18
3
2
23
Jul 2017
5
1
1
7
Aug 2017
3
2
0
5
Sep 2017
3
2
0
5
Oct 2017
2
0
2
Nov 2017
4
5
0
9
Dec 2017
6
1
0
7
Jan 2018
7
2
0
9
Feb 2018
11
1
2
14
Mar 2018
6
2
0
8
Apr 2018
6
4
0
10
May 2018
7
3
0
10
Jun 2018
4
2
0
6
Jul 2018
4
3
0
7
Aug 2018
5
6
0
11
Sep 2018
10
7
0
17
Oct 2018
7
8
0
15
Nov 2018
12
7
0
19
Dec 2018
5
4
0
9
Jan 2019
7
5
0
12
Feb 2019
6
4
0
10
Mar 2019
4
5
0
9
Apr 2019
4
3
0
7
May 2019
4
6
0
10
Jun 2019
6
4
0
10
Jul 2019
7
2
0
9
Aug 2019
7
3
0
10
Sep 2019
3
1
0
4
Oct 2019
2
3
0
5
Nov 2019
2
1
0
3
Dec 2019
4
1
0
5
Jan 2020
5
4
0
9
Feb 2020
5
2
0
7
Mar 2020
3
1
0
4
Apr 2020
2
2
0
4
May 2020
2
1
0
3
Jun 2020
10
1
0
11
Jul 2020
13
10
7
30
Aug 2020
8
4
4
16
Sep 2020
6
5
0
11
Oct 2020
3
3
1
7
Nov 2020
6
3
1
10
Dec 2020
7
6
1
14
Jan 2021
8
7
0
15
Feb 2021
10
2
0
12
Mar 2021
7
1
0
8
Apr 2021
3
4
0
7
May 2021
6
3
0
9
Jun 2021
3
0
3
Jul 2021
7
3
0
10
Aug 2021
4
0
4
Sep 2021
7
1
0
8
Oct 2021
8
7
0
15
Nov 2021
9
6
0
15
Dec 2021
10
5
0
15
Jan 2022
5
2
0
7
Feb 2022
10
1
0
11
Mar 2022
8
1
1
10
Apr 2022
6
3
1
10
May 2022
8
1
0
9
Jun 2022
6
1
0
7
Jul 2022
20
2
0
22
Aug 2022
15
4
0
19
Sep 2022
5
2
0
7
Oct 2022
13
1
0
14
Nov 2022
6
4
0
10
Dec 2022
12
7
0
19
Jan 2023
20
10
9
39
Feb 2023
16
5
0
21
Mar 2023
9
0
9
Apr 2023
8
1
0
9
May 2023
5
2
0
7
Jun 2023
6
3
0
9
Jul 2023
14
2
16
Aug 2023
7
4
0
11
Sep 2023
10
2
1
13
Oct 2023
11
3
3
17
Nov 2023
9
1
0
10
Dec 2023
8
1
1
10
Jan 2024
11
1
0
12
Feb 2024
12
1
1
14
Mar 2024
11
0
11
Apr 2024
17
4
9
30
May 2024
10
1
6
17
Jun 2024
19
4
2
25
Jul 2024
11
3
3
17
Aug 2024
8
1
0
9
Sep 2024
6
1
0
7
Oct 2024
6
2
0
8
Nov 2024
7
0
7
Dec 2024
4
3
0
7
Jan 2025
11
2
2
15
Feb 2025
7
5
1
13
Mar 2025
9
6
0
15
Apr 2025
7
4
0
11
May 2025
8
2
2
12
Jun 2025
20
1
0
21
Jul 2025
16
6
2
24
Aug 2025
62
2
4
68
Sep 2025
314
2
1
317
Oct 2025
22
6
0
28
Nov 2025
21
8
4
33
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 03 Apr 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Apr 2013
51
92
6
May 2013
73
130
10
Jun 2013
83
143
10
Jul 2013
95
158
10
Aug 2013
99
169
11
Sep 2013
109
179
11
Oct 2013
125
191
11
Nov 2013
138
206
11
Dec 2013
147
226
11
Jan 2014
155
242
11
Feb 2014
167
257
14
Mar 2014
174
268
16
Apr 2014
180
276
16
May 2014
180
283
16
Jun 2014
185
298
16
Jul 2014
188
307
16
Aug 2014
191
317
16
Sep 2014
196
326
16
Oct 2014
197
334
16
Nov 2014
207
352
16
Dec 2014
213
363
17
Jan 2015
223
372
18
Feb 2015
232
380
18
Mar 2015
246
388
19
Apr 2015
257
390
19
May 2015
258
392
19
Jun 2015
269
397
19
Jul 2015
282
407
21
Aug 2015
287
414
21
Sep 2015
294
418
21
Oct 2015
303
427
21
Nov 2015
311
432
21
Dec 2015
315
440
21
Jan 2016
329
448
21
Feb 2016
338
459
22
Mar 2016
348
467
22
Apr 2016
353
476
22
May 2016
357
480
22
Jun 2016
361
484
22
Jul 2016
365
486
23
Aug 2016
371
492
23
Sep 2016
375
492
23
Oct 2016
378
495
30
Nov 2016
381
496
38
Dec 2016
381
498
38
Jan 2017
389
500
38
Feb 2017
396
500
39
Mar 2017
413
505
39
Apr 2017
429
506
41
May 2017
447
507
43
Jun 2017
465
510
45
Jul 2017
470
511
46
Aug 2017
473
513
46
Sep 2017
476
515
46
Oct 2017
478
515
46
Nov 2017
482
520
46
Dec 2017
488
521
46
Jan 2018
495
523
46
Feb 2018
506
524
48
Mar 2018
512
526
48
Apr 2018
518
530
48
May 2018
525
533
48
Jun 2018
529
535
48
Jul 2018
533
538
48
Aug 2018
538
544
48
Sep 2018
548
551
48
Oct 2018
555
559
48
Nov 2018
567
566
48
Dec 2018
572
570
48
Jan 2019
579
575
48
Feb 2019
585
579
48
Mar 2019
589
584
48
Apr 2019
593
587
48
May 2019
597
593
48
Jun 2019
603
597
48
Jul 2019
610
599
48
Aug 2019
617
602
48
Sep 2019
620
603
48
Oct 2019
622
606
48
Nov 2019
624
607
48
Dec 2019
628
608
48
Jan 2020
633
612
48
Feb 2020
638
614
48
Mar 2020
641
615
48
Apr 2020
643
617
48
May 2020
645
618
48
Jun 2020
655
619
48
Jul 2020
668
629
55
Aug 2020
676
633
59
Sep 2020
682
638
59
Oct 2020
685
641
60
Nov 2020
691
644
61
Dec 2020
698
650
62
Jan 2021
706
657
62
Feb 2021
716
659
62
Mar 2021
723
660
62
Apr 2021
726
664
62
May 2021
732
667
62
Jun 2021
735
667
62
Jul 2021
742
670
62
Aug 2021
746
670
62
Sep 2021
753
671
62
Oct 2021
761
678
62
Nov 2021
770
684
62
Dec 2021
780
689
62
Jan 2022
785
691
62
Feb 2022
795
692
62
Mar 2022
803
693
63
Apr 2022
809
696
64
May 2022
817
697
64
Jun 2022
823
698
64
Jul 2022
843
700
64
Aug 2022
858
704
64
Sep 2022
863
706
64
Oct 2022
876
707
64
Nov 2022
882
711
64
Dec 2022
894
718
64
Jan 2023
914
728
73
Feb 2023
930
733
73
Mar 2023
939
733
73
Apr 2023
947
734
73
May 2023
952
736
73
Jun 2023
958
739
73
Jul 2023
972
739
75
Aug 2023
979
743
75
Sep 2023
989
745
76
Oct 2023
1,000
748
79
Nov 2023
1,009
749
79
Dec 2023
1,017
750
80
Jan 2024
1,028
751
80
Feb 2024
1,040
752
81
Mar 2024
1,051
752
81
Apr 2024
1,068
756
90
May 2024
1,078
757
96
Jun 2024
1,097
761
98
Jul 2024
1,108
764
101
Aug 2024
1,116
765
101
Sep 2024
1,122
766
101
Oct 2024
1,128
768
101
Nov 2024
1,135
768
101
Dec 2024
1,139
771
101
Jan 2025
1,150
773
103
Feb 2025
1,157
778
104
Mar 2025
1,166
784
104
Apr 2025
1,173
788
104
May 2025
1,181
790
106
Jun 2025
1,201
791
106
Jul 2025
1,217
797
108
Aug 2025
1,279
799
112
Sep 2025
1,593
801
113
Oct 2025
1,615
807
113
Nov 2025
1,636
815
117
Latest update: 27 Nov 2025