A. Rana , L. Bengtsson , J. Olsson , and V. Jothiprakash
Efficient design of urban drainage systems is based on statistical analysis of past rainfall events at fine time scales. However, fine time scale rainfall data are usually lacking in many parts of the world. A possible way forward is to develop methods to derive fine time scale rain intensities from daily observations. This paper applied cascade-based disaggregation modeling for generation of fine time scale rainfall data for Mumbai, India from daily rainfall data. These data were disaggregated to 10-min values. The model was used to disaggregate daily data for the period 1951–2004 and develop intensity-duration-frequency (IDF) relationships. This disaggregation technique is commonly used assuming scale-invariance using constant parameters. For the Mumbai rains it was found better to use parameters dependent on time scale and rain volume. Very good agreement between modeled and observed disaggregation series was found for the time scales larger than 1/2 h for the 1/2-yr period when short term data were available. Although the parameters were allowed to change with time scale, the rain intensities of duration shorter than 1/2 h were overestimated. When IDF-curves had been established, they showed that the current design standard for Mumbai city, 25 mm h−1 , has a return period of less than one year. Thus, annual recurring flooding problems in Mumbai appear evident.
Received: 20 Mar 2013 – Discussion started: 11 Apr 2013
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
A. Rana , L. Bengtsson , J. Olsson , and V. Jothiprakash
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
A. Rana , L. Bengtsson , J. Olsson , and V. Jothiprakash
A. Rana , L. Bengtsson , J. Olsson , and V. Jothiprakash
Viewed
Total article views: 2,597 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,468
1,000
129
2,597
131
135
HTML: 1,468
PDF: 1,000
XML: 129
Total: 2,597
BibTeX: 131
EndNote: 135
Views and downloads (calculated since 11 Apr 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Apr 2013
83
59
4
146
May 2013
19
45
4
68
Jun 2013
30
15
0
45
Jul 2013
57
23
1
81
Aug 2013
29
12
0
41
Sep 2013
16
21
1
38
Oct 2013
28
22
0
50
Nov 2013
16
26
1
43
Dec 2013
17
26
3
46
Jan 2014
13
19
4
36
Feb 2014
14
34
4
52
Mar 2014
17
26
2
45
Apr 2014
10
27
2
39
May 2014
8
35
0
43
Jun 2014
8
17
0
25
Jul 2014
3
20
1
24
Aug 2014
10
12
0
22
Sep 2014
11
29
1
41
Oct 2014
6
16
1
23
Nov 2014
5
19
0
24
Dec 2014
2
19
1
22
Jan 2015
5
9
0
14
Feb 2015
8
2
0
10
Mar 2015
8
1
0
9
Apr 2015
11
4
0
15
May 2015
1
2
0
3
Jun 2015
7
6
0
13
Jul 2015
7
0
7
Aug 2015
4
2
0
6
Sep 2015
3
2
0
5
Oct 2015
7
2
0
9
Nov 2015
7
3
0
10
Dec 2015
4
0
4
Jan 2016
13
6
0
19
Feb 2016
9
4
1
14
Mar 2016
6
4
0
10
Apr 2016
3
6
0
9
May 2016
2
6
0
8
Jun 2016
5
3
0
8
Jul 2016
7
2
1
10
Aug 2016
6
5
0
11
Sep 2016
5
5
0
10
Oct 2016
3
1
7
11
Nov 2016
6
3
8
17
Dec 2016
1
2
0
3
Jan 2017
9
4
1
14
Feb 2017
6
0
6
Mar 2017
16
7
0
23
Apr 2017
16
3
2
21
May 2017
16
4
3
23
Jun 2017
19
3
3
25
Jul 2017
5
5
1
11
Aug 2017
3
6
0
9
Sep 2017
5
1
0
6
Oct 2017
3
3
0
6
Nov 2017
5
4
0
9
Dec 2017
6
2
0
8
Jan 2018
9
5
0
14
Feb 2018
11
2
13
Mar 2018
4
4
0
8
Apr 2018
14
8
0
22
May 2018
12
4
1
17
Jun 2018
7
4
1
12
Jul 2018
4
2
0
6
Aug 2018
8
22
0
30
Sep 2018
11
9
0
20
Oct 2018
7
4
0
11
Nov 2018
6
4
0
10
Dec 2018
5
5
0
10
Jan 2019
8
5
0
13
Feb 2019
4
2
0
6
Mar 2019
2
2
0
4
Apr 2019
5
5
0
10
May 2019
3
6
0
9
Jun 2019
11
2
0
13
Jul 2019
9
3
0
12
Aug 2019
6
5
0
11
Sep 2019
3
2
0
5
Oct 2019
3
2
0
5
Nov 2019
2
0
2
Dec 2019
2
0
2
Jan 2020
1
0
1
Feb 2020
5
5
0
10
Mar 2020
1
1
0
2
Apr 2020
1
4
0
5
May 2020
7
3
1
11
Jun 2020
6
0
6
Jul 2020
20
9
10
39
Aug 2020
6
6
4
16
Sep 2020
5
7
0
12
Oct 2020
5
6
1
12
Nov 2020
7
4
1
12
Dec 2020
8
8
1
17
Jan 2021
12
4
0
16
Feb 2021
7
7
0
14
Mar 2021
10
4
0
14
Apr 2021
3
4
0
7
May 2021
5
6
0
11
Jun 2021
9
4
0
13
Jul 2021
10
3
1
14
Aug 2021
13
4
0
17
Sep 2021
10
0
10
Oct 2021
18
11
0
29
Nov 2021
11
4
4
19
Dec 2021
16
4
0
20
Jan 2022
14
6
1
21
Feb 2022
17
2
0
19
Mar 2022
20
7
1
28
Apr 2022
18
2
1
21
May 2022
17
3
0
20
Jun 2022
5
4
0
9
Jul 2022
20
2
0
22
Aug 2022
14
4
1
19
Sep 2022
11
4
0
15
Oct 2022
10
3
0
13
Nov 2022
6
3
0
9
Dec 2022
6
3
1
10
Jan 2023
16
14
11
41
Feb 2023
12
6
0
18
Mar 2023
5
2
1
8
Apr 2023
6
2
0
8
May 2023
2
4
0
6
Jun 2023
4
1
1
6
Jul 2023
12
4
1
17
Aug 2023
6
4
0
10
Sep 2023
10
1
1
12
Oct 2023
5
2
0
7
Nov 2023
9
1
0
10
Dec 2023
3
2
0
5
Jan 2024
7
1
1
9
Feb 2024
11
3
3
17
Mar 2024
11
7
1
19
Apr 2024
10
1
7
18
May 2024
9
3
0
12
Jun 2024
29
2
2
33
Jul 2024
13
1
2
16
Aug 2024
2
1
0
3
Sep 2024
8
4
0
12
Oct 2024
9
4
0
13
Nov 2024
23
2
0
25
Dec 2024
10
0
10
Jan 2025
14
2
2
18
Feb 2025
10
2
2
14
Mar 2025
16
2
1
19
Apr 2025
3
4
3
10
May 2025
12
6
0
18
Jun 2025
18
1
1
20
Jul 2025
10
4
0
14
Aug 2025
1
0
1
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 11 Apr 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Apr 2013
83
59
4
May 2013
102
104
8
Jun 2013
132
119
8
Jul 2013
189
142
9
Aug 2013
218
154
9
Sep 2013
234
175
10
Oct 2013
262
197
10
Nov 2013
278
223
11
Dec 2013
295
249
14
Jan 2014
308
268
18
Feb 2014
322
302
22
Mar 2014
339
328
24
Apr 2014
349
355
26
May 2014
357
390
26
Jun 2014
365
407
26
Jul 2014
368
427
27
Aug 2014
378
439
27
Sep 2014
389
468
28
Oct 2014
395
484
29
Nov 2014
400
503
29
Dec 2014
402
522
30
Jan 2015
407
531
30
Feb 2015
415
533
30
Mar 2015
423
534
30
Apr 2015
434
538
30
May 2015
435
540
30
Jun 2015
442
546
30
Jul 2015
449
546
30
Aug 2015
453
548
30
Sep 2015
456
550
30
Oct 2015
463
552
30
Nov 2015
470
555
30
Dec 2015
470
559
30
Jan 2016
483
565
30
Feb 2016
492
569
31
Mar 2016
498
573
31
Apr 2016
501
579
31
May 2016
503
585
31
Jun 2016
508
588
31
Jul 2016
515
590
32
Aug 2016
521
595
32
Sep 2016
526
600
32
Oct 2016
529
601
39
Nov 2016
535
604
47
Dec 2016
536
606
47
Jan 2017
545
610
48
Feb 2017
551
610
48
Mar 2017
567
617
48
Apr 2017
583
620
50
May 2017
599
624
53
Jun 2017
618
627
56
Jul 2017
623
632
57
Aug 2017
626
638
57
Sep 2017
631
639
57
Oct 2017
634
642
57
Nov 2017
639
646
57
Dec 2017
645
648
57
Jan 2018
654
653
57
Feb 2018
665
653
59
Mar 2018
669
657
59
Apr 2018
683
665
59
May 2018
695
669
60
Jun 2018
702
673
61
Jul 2018
706
675
61
Aug 2018
714
697
61
Sep 2018
725
706
61
Oct 2018
732
710
61
Nov 2018
738
714
61
Dec 2018
743
719
61
Jan 2019
751
724
61
Feb 2019
755
726
61
Mar 2019
757
728
61
Apr 2019
762
733
61
May 2019
765
739
61
Jun 2019
776
741
61
Jul 2019
785
744
61
Aug 2019
791
749
61
Sep 2019
794
751
61
Oct 2019
797
753
61
Nov 2019
799
753
61
Dec 2019
799
755
61
Jan 2020
799
756
61
Feb 2020
804
761
61
Mar 2020
805
762
61
Apr 2020
806
766
61
May 2020
813
769
62
Jun 2020
819
769
62
Jul 2020
839
778
72
Aug 2020
845
784
76
Sep 2020
850
791
76
Oct 2020
855
797
77
Nov 2020
862
801
78
Dec 2020
870
809
79
Jan 2021
882
813
79
Feb 2021
889
820
79
Mar 2021
899
824
79
Apr 2021
902
828
79
May 2021
907
834
79
Jun 2021
916
838
79
Jul 2021
926
841
80
Aug 2021
939
845
80
Sep 2021
949
845
80
Oct 2021
967
856
80
Nov 2021
978
860
84
Dec 2021
994
864
84
Jan 2022
1,008
870
85
Feb 2022
1,025
872
85
Mar 2022
1,045
879
86
Apr 2022
1,063
881
87
May 2022
1,080
884
87
Jun 2022
1,085
888
87
Jul 2022
1,105
890
87
Aug 2022
1,119
894
88
Sep 2022
1,130
898
88
Oct 2022
1,140
901
88
Nov 2022
1,146
904
88
Dec 2022
1,152
907
89
Jan 2023
1,168
921
100
Feb 2023
1,180
927
100
Mar 2023
1,185
929
101
Apr 2023
1,191
931
101
May 2023
1,193
935
101
Jun 2023
1,197
936
102
Jul 2023
1,209
940
103
Aug 2023
1,215
944
103
Sep 2023
1,225
945
104
Oct 2023
1,230
947
104
Nov 2023
1,239
948
104
Dec 2023
1,242
950
104
Jan 2024
1,249
951
105
Feb 2024
1,260
954
108
Mar 2024
1,271
961
109
Apr 2024
1,281
962
116
May 2024
1,290
965
116
Jun 2024
1,319
967
118
Jul 2024
1,332
968
120
Aug 2024
1,334
969
120
Sep 2024
1,342
973
120
Oct 2024
1,351
977
120
Nov 2024
1,374
979
120
Dec 2024
1,384
979
120
Jan 2025
1,398
981
122
Feb 2025
1,408
983
124
Mar 2025
1,424
985
125
Apr 2025
1,427
989
128
May 2025
1,439
995
128
Jun 2025
1,457
996
129
Jul 2025
1,467
1,000
129
Aug 2025
1,468
1,000
129
Cited
Saved
Latest update: 14 Aug 2025