S. Bastola , C. Murphy , and J. Sweeney
Conceptual hydrological models are widely used for climate change impact assessment. The implicit assumption in most such work is that the parameters estimated from observations remain valid for future climatic conditions. This paper evaluates a simple threshold based approach for testing this assumption, where a set of behavioural simulators are identified for different climatic conditions for the future simulation i.e. wet, average and dry conditions. These simulators were derived using three different data sets that are generated by sampling a block of one year of data without replacement from the observations such that they define the different climatic conditions. The simulators estimated from the wet climatic data set showed the tendency to underestimate flow when applied to dry data set and vice versa. However, the performances of the three sets of basin simulators on chronologically coherent data are identical to the simulators identified from a sufficiently long data series that contains both wet and dry climatic conditions. The results presented suggest that the issue of time invariance in the value of parameters has a minimal effect on the simulation if the change in precipitation is less than 10 % of the data used for calibration.
Received: 31 May 2011 – Discussion started: 22 Jun 2011
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
S. Bastola , C. Murphy , and J. Sweeney
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
S. Bastola , C. Murphy , and J. Sweeney
S. Bastola , C. Murphy , and J. Sweeney
Viewed
Total article views: 2,935 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,528
1,306
101
2,935
116
138
HTML: 1,528
PDF: 1,306
XML: 101
Total: 2,935
BibTeX: 116
EndNote: 138
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Feb 2013
4
8
1
13
Mar 2013
2
6
0
8
Apr 2013
3
3
1
7
May 2013
8
8
0
16
Jun 2013
5
8
0
13
Jul 2013
6
7
0
13
Aug 2013
1
4
0
5
Sep 2013
4
8
0
12
Oct 2013
6
11
0
17
Nov 2013
6
12
0
18
Dec 2013
9
8
0
17
Jan 2014
4
11
0
15
Feb 2014
9
18
2
29
Mar 2014
3
8
0
11
Apr 2014
5
11
0
16
May 2014
4
7
0
11
Jun 2014
5
9
0
14
Jul 2014
5
14
0
19
Aug 2014
2
11
0
13
Sep 2014
4
8
0
12
Oct 2014
3
8
0
11
Nov 2014
2
35
0
37
Dec 2014
1
485
0
486
Jan 2015
3
239
0
242
Feb 2015
6
5
0
11
Mar 2015
7
4
0
11
Apr 2015
10
2
0
12
May 2015
1
4
0
5
Jun 2015
5
2
0
7
Jul 2015
10
7
0
17
Aug 2015
5
3
0
8
Sep 2015
2
1
0
3
Oct 2015
5
1
0
6
Nov 2015
6
1
0
7
Dec 2015
3
0
3
Jan 2016
9
7
0
16
Feb 2016
7
4
1
12
Mar 2016
8
0
8
Apr 2016
7
4
0
11
May 2016
4
1
0
5
Jun 2016
7
4
0
11
Jul 2016
8
3
1
12
Aug 2016
3
5
0
8
Sep 2016
3
0
3
Oct 2016
3
2
9
14
Nov 2016
3
2
9
14
Dec 2016
3
2
0
5
Jan 2017
2
1
0
3
Feb 2017
3
0
3
Mar 2017
17
8
0
25
Apr 2017
15
2
17
May 2017
18
2
2
22
Jun 2017
20
1
1
22
Jul 2017
8
4
1
13
Aug 2017
3
2
0
5
Sep 2017
4
2
0
6
Oct 2017
1
1
0
2
Nov 2017
5
1
0
6
Dec 2017
5
2
0
7
Jan 2018
9
3
0
12
Feb 2018
13
4
2
19
Mar 2018
8
6
1
15
Apr 2018
6
4
0
10
May 2018
7
3
0
10
Jun 2018
4
4
0
8
Jul 2018
3
2
0
5
Aug 2018
6
4
0
10
Sep 2018
7
5
0
12
Oct 2018
13
8
1
22
Nov 2018
6
6
0
12
Dec 2018
4
2
0
6
Jan 2019
9
7
0
16
Feb 2019
7
4
0
11
Mar 2019
2
2
0
4
Apr 2019
5
6
0
11
May 2019
5
4
0
9
Jun 2019
5
4
0
9
Jul 2019
9
3
0
12
Aug 2019
4
1
0
5
Sep 2019
4
2
0
6
Oct 2019
3
3
0
6
Nov 2019
3
2
0
5
Dec 2019
4
1
0
5
Jan 2020
3
3
0
6
Feb 2020
6
3
0
9
Mar 2020
1
0
1
Apr 2020
1
1
0
2
May 2020
2
1
1
4
Jun 2020
6
4
0
10
Jul 2020
14
9
9
32
Aug 2020
6
3
4
13
Sep 2020
5
1
0
6
Oct 2020
5
3
0
8
Nov 2020
3
2
1
6
Dec 2020
6
3
0
9
Jan 2021
8
6
0
14
Feb 2021
6
4
0
10
Mar 2021
7
4
2
13
Apr 2021
3
4
0
7
May 2021
7
2
0
9
Jun 2021
6
4
0
10
Jul 2021
8
2
0
10
Aug 2021
7
1
0
8
Sep 2021
11
1
0
12
Oct 2021
10
3
0
13
Nov 2021
8
5
0
13
Dec 2021
10
2
0
12
Jan 2022
14
5
0
19
Feb 2022
13
2
0
15
Mar 2022
8
1
1
10
Apr 2022
12
4
2
18
May 2022
13
1
0
14
Jun 2022
8
3
0
11
Jul 2022
23
1
0
24
Aug 2022
15
1
0
16
Sep 2022
15
2
0
17
Oct 2022
28
1
1
30
Nov 2022
16
5
1
22
Dec 2022
22
1
1
24
Jan 2023
15
1
2
18
Feb 2023
15
2
1
18
Mar 2023
9
5
0
14
Apr 2023
5
4
0
9
May 2023
8
2
0
10
Jun 2023
6
2
1
9
Jul 2023
14
3
6
23
Aug 2023
13
2
1
16
Sep 2023
10
2
1
13
Oct 2023
6
4
2
12
Nov 2023
9
4
0
13
Dec 2023
6
1
1
8
Jan 2024
11
2
1
14
Feb 2024
6
2
1
9
Mar 2024
22
0
22
Apr 2024
22
12
6
40
May 2024
5
2
2
9
Jun 2024
5
2
1
8
Jul 2024
7
1
2
10
Aug 2024
6
2
0
8
Sep 2024
9
1
0
10
Oct 2024
3
1
0
4
Nov 2024
4
0
4
Dec 2024
10
1
0
11
Jan 2025
10
4
3
17
Feb 2025
8
3
3
14
Mar 2025
11
2
2
15
Apr 2025
7
3
3
13
May 2025
11
2
1
14
Jun 2025
21
0
21
Jul 2025
11
2
0
13
Aug 2025
68
1
3
72
Sep 2025
310
1
1
312
Oct 2025
23
2
0
25
Nov 2025
14
1
0
15
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Feb 2013
4
8
1
Mar 2013
6
14
1
Apr 2013
9
17
2
May 2013
17
25
2
Jun 2013
22
33
2
Jul 2013
28
40
2
Aug 2013
29
44
2
Sep 2013
33
52
2
Oct 2013
39
63
2
Nov 2013
45
75
2
Dec 2013
54
83
2
Jan 2014
58
94
2
Feb 2014
67
112
4
Mar 2014
70
120
4
Apr 2014
75
131
4
May 2014
79
138
4
Jun 2014
84
147
4
Jul 2014
89
161
4
Aug 2014
91
172
4
Sep 2014
95
180
4
Oct 2014
98
188
4
Nov 2014
100
223
4
Dec 2014
101
708
4
Jan 2015
104
947
4
Feb 2015
110
952
4
Mar 2015
117
956
4
Apr 2015
127
958
4
May 2015
128
962
4
Jun 2015
133
964
4
Jul 2015
143
971
4
Aug 2015
148
974
4
Sep 2015
150
975
4
Oct 2015
155
976
4
Nov 2015
161
977
4
Dec 2015
161
980
4
Jan 2016
170
987
4
Feb 2016
177
991
5
Mar 2016
185
991
5
Apr 2016
192
995
5
May 2016
196
996
5
Jun 2016
203
1,000
5
Jul 2016
211
1,003
6
Aug 2016
214
1,008
6
Sep 2016
217
1,008
6
Oct 2016
220
1,010
15
Nov 2016
223
1,012
24
Dec 2016
226
1,014
24
Jan 2017
228
1,015
24
Feb 2017
231
1,015
24
Mar 2017
248
1,023
24
Apr 2017
263
1,023
26
May 2017
281
1,025
28
Jun 2017
301
1,026
29
Jul 2017
309
1,030
30
Aug 2017
312
1,032
30
Sep 2017
316
1,034
30
Oct 2017
317
1,035
30
Nov 2017
322
1,036
30
Dec 2017
327
1,038
30
Jan 2018
336
1,041
30
Feb 2018
349
1,045
32
Mar 2018
357
1,051
33
Apr 2018
363
1,055
33
May 2018
370
1,058
33
Jun 2018
374
1,062
33
Jul 2018
377
1,064
33
Aug 2018
383
1,068
33
Sep 2018
390
1,073
33
Oct 2018
403
1,081
34
Nov 2018
409
1,087
34
Dec 2018
413
1,089
34
Jan 2019
422
1,096
34
Feb 2019
429
1,100
34
Mar 2019
431
1,102
34
Apr 2019
436
1,108
34
May 2019
441
1,112
34
Jun 2019
446
1,116
34
Jul 2019
455
1,119
34
Aug 2019
459
1,120
34
Sep 2019
463
1,122
34
Oct 2019
466
1,125
34
Nov 2019
469
1,127
34
Dec 2019
473
1,128
34
Jan 2020
476
1,131
34
Feb 2020
482
1,134
34
Mar 2020
482
1,135
34
Apr 2020
483
1,136
34
May 2020
485
1,137
35
Jun 2020
491
1,141
35
Jul 2020
505
1,150
44
Aug 2020
511
1,153
48
Sep 2020
516
1,154
48
Oct 2020
521
1,157
48
Nov 2020
524
1,159
49
Dec 2020
530
1,162
49
Jan 2021
538
1,168
49
Feb 2021
544
1,172
49
Mar 2021
551
1,176
51
Apr 2021
554
1,180
51
May 2021
561
1,182
51
Jun 2021
567
1,186
51
Jul 2021
575
1,188
51
Aug 2021
582
1,189
51
Sep 2021
593
1,190
51
Oct 2021
603
1,193
51
Nov 2021
611
1,198
51
Dec 2021
621
1,200
51
Jan 2022
635
1,205
51
Feb 2022
648
1,207
51
Mar 2022
656
1,208
52
Apr 2022
668
1,212
54
May 2022
681
1,213
54
Jun 2022
689
1,216
54
Jul 2022
712
1,217
54
Aug 2022
727
1,218
54
Sep 2022
742
1,220
54
Oct 2022
770
1,221
55
Nov 2022
786
1,226
56
Dec 2022
808
1,227
57
Jan 2023
823
1,228
59
Feb 2023
838
1,230
60
Mar 2023
847
1,235
60
Apr 2023
852
1,239
60
May 2023
860
1,241
60
Jun 2023
866
1,243
61
Jul 2023
880
1,246
67
Aug 2023
893
1,248
68
Sep 2023
903
1,250
69
Oct 2023
909
1,254
71
Nov 2023
918
1,258
71
Dec 2023
924
1,259
72
Jan 2024
935
1,261
73
Feb 2024
941
1,263
74
Mar 2024
963
1,263
74
Apr 2024
985
1,275
80
May 2024
990
1,277
82
Jun 2024
995
1,279
83
Jul 2024
1,002
1,280
85
Aug 2024
1,008
1,282
85
Sep 2024
1,017
1,283
85
Oct 2024
1,020
1,284
85
Nov 2024
1,024
1,284
85
Dec 2024
1,034
1,285
85
Jan 2025
1,044
1,289
88
Feb 2025
1,052
1,292
91
Mar 2025
1,063
1,294
93
Apr 2025
1,070
1,297
96
May 2025
1,081
1,299
97
Jun 2025
1,102
1,299
97
Jul 2025
1,113
1,301
97
Aug 2025
1,181
1,302
100
Sep 2025
1,491
1,303
101
Oct 2025
1,514
1,305
101
Nov 2025
1,528
1,306
101
Latest update: 26 Nov 2025