Dear Authors,
I thank you for your replies, where you have adequately addressed all the points raised by the referees (including Wouter: if he had not commented as soon as the paper was published I would have nominated him too...). All the referees expressed very positive opinions on your work and they provided very useful and constructive comments to further improve the presentation of your work (no important additional analyses were suggested); your replies already indicate where you are planning to modify the manuscript, that I assume is practically ready, and I warmly invite you to submit it promptly.
As I had already written, the theme is very important: of course I may be influenced by my personal research focus, but I believe that the lively and thoughtful discussion demonstrated that your work did and will indeed arouse much interest in our community at large.
Best wishes, Elena

Dear Manuela and all authors,
your submission of the revised paper, as anticipated in your replies, adequately addresses all the minor revision required by the referees.
Thank you for having submitted your paper that, as I wrote more than once, will certainly be of interest for many HESS readers.
Best wishes,
Elena