Articles | Volume 21, issue 7
Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 21, 3325–3352, 2017
Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 21, 3325–3352, 2017

Research article 05 Jul 2017

Research article | 05 Jul 2017

Characterizing and reducing equifinality by constraining a distributed catchment model with regional signatures, local observations, and process understanding

Christa Kelleher1,2, Brian McGlynn2, and Thorsten Wagener3,4 Christa Kelleher et al.
  • 1Department of Earth Sciences, Syracuse University, Syracuse, NY, 13244, USA
  • 2Department of Earth and Ocean Sciences, Nicholas School of the Environment, Duke University, Durham, NC, 27706, USA
  • 3Department of Civil Engineering, University of Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1TR, UK
  • 4Cabot Institute, University of Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1TR, UK

Abstract. Distributed catchment models are widely used tools for predicting hydrologic behavior. While distributed models require many parameters to describe a system, they are expected to simulate behavior that is more consistent with observed processes. However, obtaining a single set of acceptable parameters can be problematic, as parameter equifinality often results in several behavioral sets that fit observations (typically streamflow). In this study, we investigate the extent to which equifinality impacts a typical distributed modeling application. We outline a hierarchical approach to reduce the number of behavioral sets based on regional, observation-driven, and expert-knowledge-based constraints. For our application, we explore how each of these constraint classes reduced the number of behavioral parameter sets and altered distributions of spatiotemporal simulations, simulating a well-studied headwater catchment, Stringer Creek, Montana, using the distributed hydrology–soil–vegetation model (DHSVM). As a demonstrative exercise, we investigated model performance across 10 000 parameter sets. Constraints on regional signatures, the hydrograph, and two internal measurements of snow water equivalent time series reduced the number of behavioral parameter sets but still left a small number with similar goodness of fit. This subset was ultimately further reduced by incorporating pattern expectations of groundwater table depth across the catchment. Our results suggest that utilizing a hierarchical approach based on regional datasets, observations, and expert knowledge to identify behavioral parameter sets can reduce equifinality and bolster more careful application and simulation of spatiotemporal processes via distributed modeling at the catchment scale.

Short summary
Models are tools for understanding how watersheds function and may respond to land cover and climate change. Before we can use models towards these purposes, we need to ensure that a model adequately represents watershed-wide observations. In this paper, we propose a new way to evaluate whether model simulations match observations, using a variety of information sources. We show how this information can reduce uncertainty in inputs to models, reducing uncertainty in hydrologic predictions.