Soil moisture products consistency for operational drought monitoring in Europe

Abstract. The roadmap to enable operational soil moisture (SM) monitoring for meteorologic and hydrological early warning is challenged by the uncertainty within the available remote sensing and modelling products. This study addressed two relevant uncertainties: the residual trends in the series and the spatial consistency. While the latter has been often revisited to validate remote sensing and modelling products against in-situ data, the former is often disregarded in studies addressing SM changes.

This study evaluated three SM products: (1) the Satellite Application Facility on Support to Operational Hydrology and Water Management (H SAF) active Advanced SCATterometer (ASCAT)-derived dataset, (2) the passive subset of the European Space Agency (ESA) - Climate Change Initiative (CCIp), and (3) the modelled dataset from the European Drought Observatory (EDO). The analysis was carried out over Europe in the period 2007–2022 at 10-day temporal scales.

We obtained that even these popular datasets are subject to patches of spatial inconsistency and residual trends when compared to the in-situ data from the International Soil Moisture Network (ISMN). In view of the great complementarity shown by the active and passive remote sensing and the modelled SM estimates, two merged products are proposed and tested against in-situ data. Results indicate that combining H SAF ASCAT, CCIp and EDO equals or surpasses the spatial and temporal consistency of the individual SM products alone, even when only the near-real-time products of H SAF ASCAT and EDO are combined. Thus, merging remote sensing and modelled SM products is advantageous for enhanced spatial and temporal operational monitoring of SM at the European scale.