the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.
Theory of the generalized chloride mass balance method for recharge estimation in groundwater basins characterised by point and diffuse recharge
Abstract. Application of the conventional chloride mass balance (CMB) method to point recharge dominant groundwater basins can substantially under-estimate long-term average annual recharge by not accounting for the effects of localized surface water inputs. This is because the conventional CMB method ignores the duality of infiltration and recharge found in karstic systems, where point recharge can be a contributing factor. When point recharge is present in groundwater basins, recharge estimation is unsuccessful using the conventional CMB method with, either unsaturated zone chloride or groundwater chloride. In this paper we describe a generalized CMB that can be applied to groundwater basins with point recharge. Results from this generalized CMB are shown to be comparable with long-term recharge estimates obtained using the watertable fluctuation method, groundwater flow modelling and Darcy flow calculations. The generalized CMB method provides an alternative, reliable long-term recharge estimation method for groundwater basins characterised by both point and diffuse recharge.
- Preprint
(1886 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
-
RC C3: 'Review of Somaratne and Smettem', Anonymous Referee #1, 13 Jan 2014
- AC C18: 'Author Reply to Referee 1 - Generalized CMB Method', Nara Somaratne, 17 Jan 2014
-
SC C19: 'Discussion:Theory of the generalized chloride mass balance method for recharge estimation in groundwater basins dominated by point recharge', Warren Wood, 19 Jan 2014
- AC C32: 'Author Reply to Prof. Warren Wood- Generalized CMB method', Nara Somaratne, 30 Jan 2014
-
AC C238: 'Why the Conventional CMB Fails in Karst.', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
-
RC C266: 'Fictional notions of Somaratne and Smettem', Anonymous Referee #1, 04 Mar 2014
- AC C337: 'Author Reply to Referee 1-Fifth round of comments', Nara Somaratne, 09 Mar 2014
-
RC C266: 'Fictional notions of Somaratne and Smettem', Anonymous Referee #1, 04 Mar 2014
-
RC C87: 'Peer review 3', Anonymous Referee #2, 07 Feb 2014
- AC C235: 'Author Reply to Referee 2 - Generalized CMB', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
- AC C239: 'Why the Conventional CMB Fails in Karst.', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
-
RC C94: 'Comments on Somaratne and Smettem HESSD', Anonymous Referee #1, 08 Feb 2014
-
AC C236: 'Author Reply to Referee 1- Second round of comments', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
- AC C240: 'Why the Conventional CMB Fails in Karst.', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
-
AC C236: 'Author Reply to Referee 1- Second round of comments', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
-
RC C100: 'Additional comments on Somaratne and Smettem, HESSD', Anonymous Referee #1, 09 Feb 2014
-
AC C237: 'Author Reply to Referee 1 - Third round of comments', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
-
RC C262: 'Fictional water', Anonymous Referee #1, 04 Mar 2014
- AC C338: 'Author Reply to the Referee 1- Fourth round of comments', Nara Somaratne, 09 Mar 2014
-
RC C262: 'Fictional water', Anonymous Referee #1, 04 Mar 2014
-
AC C237: 'Author Reply to Referee 1 - Third round of comments', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
- EC C509: 'Editor comment', Insa Neuweiler, 17 Mar 2014
-
RC C3: 'Review of Somaratne and Smettem', Anonymous Referee #1, 13 Jan 2014
- AC C18: 'Author Reply to Referee 1 - Generalized CMB Method', Nara Somaratne, 17 Jan 2014
-
SC C19: 'Discussion:Theory of the generalized chloride mass balance method for recharge estimation in groundwater basins dominated by point recharge', Warren Wood, 19 Jan 2014
- AC C32: 'Author Reply to Prof. Warren Wood- Generalized CMB method', Nara Somaratne, 30 Jan 2014
-
AC C238: 'Why the Conventional CMB Fails in Karst.', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
-
RC C266: 'Fictional notions of Somaratne and Smettem', Anonymous Referee #1, 04 Mar 2014
- AC C337: 'Author Reply to Referee 1-Fifth round of comments', Nara Somaratne, 09 Mar 2014
-
RC C266: 'Fictional notions of Somaratne and Smettem', Anonymous Referee #1, 04 Mar 2014
-
RC C87: 'Peer review 3', Anonymous Referee #2, 07 Feb 2014
- AC C235: 'Author Reply to Referee 2 - Generalized CMB', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
- AC C239: 'Why the Conventional CMB Fails in Karst.', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
-
RC C94: 'Comments on Somaratne and Smettem HESSD', Anonymous Referee #1, 08 Feb 2014
-
AC C236: 'Author Reply to Referee 1- Second round of comments', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
- AC C240: 'Why the Conventional CMB Fails in Karst.', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
-
AC C236: 'Author Reply to Referee 1- Second round of comments', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
-
RC C100: 'Additional comments on Somaratne and Smettem, HESSD', Anonymous Referee #1, 09 Feb 2014
-
AC C237: 'Author Reply to Referee 1 - Third round of comments', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
-
RC C262: 'Fictional water', Anonymous Referee #1, 04 Mar 2014
- AC C338: 'Author Reply to the Referee 1- Fourth round of comments', Nara Somaratne, 09 Mar 2014
-
RC C262: 'Fictional water', Anonymous Referee #1, 04 Mar 2014
-
AC C237: 'Author Reply to Referee 1 - Third round of comments', Nara Somaratne, 02 Mar 2014
- EC C509: 'Editor comment', Insa Neuweiler, 17 Mar 2014
Viewed
HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1,998 | 821 | 107 | 2,926 | 102 | 124 |
- HTML: 1,998
- PDF: 821
- XML: 107
- Total: 2,926
- BibTeX: 102
- EndNote: 124
Cited
8 citations as recorded by crossref.
- Inter-Basin Groundwater Transfer and Multiple Approach Recharge Estimation of the Upper Awash Aquifer System B. Berehanu et al. 10.4236/gep.2017.53007
- Contrasting long-term trends of chloride levels in remote and human-disturbed lakes in south-central Ontario, Canada H. Yao et al. 10.1080/10402381.2020.1820642
- Groundwater recharge estimation in the Ziway Lake Watershed, Ethiopian Rift: an approach using SWAT and CMB techniques A. Mechal et al. 10.1007/s40899-024-01108-0
- Estimating groundwater recharge based on mass balance evaluation of unsaturated zone in a coastal catchment characterized by tropical rainforest weather conditions S. Saghravani et al. 10.1007/s12665-016-5437-4
- Multi-method groundwater recharge estimation at Eshito micro-watershed, Rift Valley Basin in Ethiopia M. Ferede et al. 10.1080/02626667.2020.1762887
- Groundwater recharge and water table response to changing conditions for aquifers at different physiography: The case of a semi-humid river catchment, northwestern highlands of Ethiopia A. Yenehun et al. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142243
- A 70-year groundwater recharge record from sandy loess in northwestern China and its climatic implications L. Deng et al. 10.1007/s12665-017-7155-y
- Estimate of regional groundwater recharge rate in the Central Haouz Plain, Morocco, using the chloride mass balance method and a geographical information system O. Ait El Mekki et al. 10.1007/s13201-015-0335-6