Ö. Sever , Ş. Tiğrek , and N. Şarlak
In this study, an alternative solution for a large dam, namely the Kayraktepe Dam in Turkey, is investigated. The dam was planned for flood control, energy generation and flow regulation for a downstream irrigation project more than 30 yr ago, but until now the project has not begun due to it receiving severe criticism about environmental and social considerations. The project formulation was redeveloped several times in the past but the options were not found to be feasible. In this study, a detailed analysis of the available feasibility studies is provided and then a new formulation, consisting of the proposed one medium dam and five run-of-river type hydropower stations instead of a large scale dam, is evaluated. The new formulation is equivalent to the existing project in terms of energy production and flood control. On the other hand, there are some benefits relative to other configurations as solutions to some of the environmental and social problems being addressed.
Received: 17 Sep 2012 – Discussion started: 16 Oct 2012
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
Ö. Sever , Ş. Tiğrek , and N. Şarlak
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Ö. Sever , Ş. Tiğrek , and N. Şarlak
Ö. Sever , Ş. Tiğrek , and N. Şarlak
Viewed
Total article views: 1,592 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
891
595
106
1,592
96
104
HTML: 891
PDF: 595
XML: 106
Total: 1,592
BibTeX: 96
EndNote: 104
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Feb 2013
6
13
1
20
Mar 2013
6
14
1
21
Apr 2013
4
8
2
14
May 2013
6
10
0
16
Jun 2013
12
6
0
18
Jul 2013
5
6
0
11
Aug 2013
6
2
8
Sep 2013
5
9
1
15
Oct 2013
3
7
4
14
Nov 2013
3
7
0
10
Dec 2013
4
7
1
12
Jan 2014
1
15
1
17
Feb 2014
9
9
4
22
Mar 2014
5
12
2
19
Apr 2014
4
6
0
10
May 2014
8
1
9
Jun 2014
4
10
0
14
Jul 2014
5
12
2
19
Aug 2014
4
11
0
15
Sep 2014
2
10
2
14
Oct 2014
5
9
0
14
Nov 2014
1
7
2
10
Dec 2014
2
15
1
18
Jan 2015
2
4
0
6
Feb 2015
6
1
0
7
Mar 2015
7
2
1
10
Apr 2015
10
3
1
14
May 2015
3
0
3
Jun 2015
6
3
0
9
Jul 2015
8
1
9
Aug 2015
2
0
2
Sep 2015
3
3
0
6
Oct 2015
5
2
1
8
Nov 2015
7
2
1
10
Dec 2015
7
0
7
Jan 2016
8
4
0
12
Feb 2016
11
3
2
16
Mar 2016
8
4
0
12
Apr 2016
7
5
0
12
May 2016
6
1
0
7
Jun 2016
9
3
0
12
Jul 2016
10
1
1
12
Aug 2016
5
2
1
8
Sep 2016
6
3
0
9
Oct 2016
4
2
10
16
Nov 2016
3
2
9
14
Dec 2016
4
0
4
Jan 2017
7
2
0
9
Feb 2017
4
2
0
6
Mar 2017
17
7
0
24
Apr 2017
16
2
1
19
May 2017
17
4
2
23
Jun 2017
16
1
1
18
Jul 2017
5
1
1
7
Aug 2017
4
5
1
10
Sep 2017
5
1
0
6
Oct 2017
3
0
3
Nov 2017
1
2
0
3
Dec 2017
6
2
0
8
Jan 2018
9
2
0
11
Feb 2018
11
2
2
15
Mar 2018
4
3
0
7
Apr 2018
5
3
0
8
May 2018
7
3
1
11
Jun 2018
4
2
0
6
Jul 2018
5
3
0
8
Aug 2018
7
4
0
11
Sep 2018
6
5
0
11
Oct 2018
4
3
0
7
Nov 2018
7
5
0
12
Dec 2018
3
4
0
7
Jan 2019
5
3
0
8
Feb 2019
4
2
0
6
Mar 2019
2
6
0
8
Apr 2019
2
2
0
4
May 2019
3
6
0
9
Jun 2019
8
5
0
13
Jul 2019
8
4
0
12
Aug 2019
5
4
0
9
Sep 2019
2
2
0
4
Oct 2019
2
2
0
4
Nov 2019
2
3
0
5
Dec 2019
1
3
0
4
Jan 2020
5
1
0
6
Feb 2020
3
2
0
5
Mar 2020
2
1
0
3
Apr 2020
2
0
2
May 2020
2
1
0
3
Jun 2020
5
3
1
9
Jul 2020
16
34
7
57
Aug 2020
2
5
3
10
Sep 2020
1
12
0
13
Oct 2020
6
2
1
9
Nov 2020
6
5
1
12
Dec 2020
6
1
1
8
Jan 2021
9
6
0
15
Feb 2021
7
6
0
13
Mar 2021
6
3
0
9
Apr 2021
3
6
0
9
May 2021
5
2
0
7
Jun 2021
7
2
0
9
Jul 2021
9
3
0
12
Aug 2021
9
2
0
11
Sep 2021
7
1
0
8
Oct 2021
12
8
0
20
Nov 2021
8
8
2
18
Dec 2021
14
3
0
17
Jan 2022
12
2
0
14
Feb 2022
13
1
14
Mar 2022
10
1
1
12
Apr 2022
9
1
1
11
May 2022
8
1
0
9
Jun 2022
1
1
0
2
Jul 2022
18
0
18
Aug 2022
6
3
0
9
Sep 2022
3
2
0
5
Oct 2022
8
2
0
10
Nov 2022
2
2
0
4
Dec 2022
6
3
1
10
Jan 2023
7
3
1
11
Feb 2023
10
3
0
13
Mar 2023
3
2
0
5
Apr 2023
3
0
3
May 2023
4
4
0
8
Jun 2023
2
0
2
Jul 2023
13
1
14
Aug 2023
5
5
1
11
Sep 2023
15
10
1
26
Oct 2023
23
4
0
27
Nov 2023
19
1
0
20
Dec 2023
11
0
11
Jan 2024
12
1
2
15
Feb 2024
15
9
1
25
Mar 2024
14
15
0
29
Apr 2024
14
4
5
23
May 2024
3
1
7
11
Jun 2024
4
1
5
Jul 2024
5
1
1
7
Aug 2024
4
2
0
6
Sep 2024
4
2
1
7
Oct 2024
3
2
0
5
Nov 2024
4
0
4
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Feb 2013
6
13
1
Mar 2013
12
27
2
Apr 2013
16
35
4
May 2013
22
45
4
Jun 2013
34
51
4
Jul 2013
39
57
4
Aug 2013
39
63
6
Sep 2013
44
72
7
Oct 2013
47
79
11
Nov 2013
50
86
11
Dec 2013
54
93
12
Jan 2014
55
108
13
Feb 2014
64
117
17
Mar 2014
69
129
19
Apr 2014
73
135
19
May 2014
73
143
20
Jun 2014
77
153
20
Jul 2014
82
165
22
Aug 2014
86
176
22
Sep 2014
88
186
24
Oct 2014
93
195
24
Nov 2014
94
202
26
Dec 2014
96
217
27
Jan 2015
98
221
27
Feb 2015
104
222
27
Mar 2015
111
224
28
Apr 2015
121
227
29
May 2015
121
230
29
Jun 2015
127
233
29
Jul 2015
135
233
30
Aug 2015
137
233
30
Sep 2015
140
236
30
Oct 2015
145
238
31
Nov 2015
152
240
32
Dec 2015
152
247
32
Jan 2016
160
251
32
Feb 2016
171
254
34
Mar 2016
179
258
34
Apr 2016
186
263
34
May 2016
192
264
34
Jun 2016
201
267
34
Jul 2016
211
268
35
Aug 2016
216
270
36
Sep 2016
222
273
36
Oct 2016
226
275
46
Nov 2016
229
277
55
Dec 2016
229
281
55
Jan 2017
236
283
55
Feb 2017
240
285
55
Mar 2017
257
292
55
Apr 2017
273
294
56
May 2017
290
298
58
Jun 2017
306
299
59
Jul 2017
311
300
60
Aug 2017
315
305
61
Sep 2017
320
306
61
Oct 2017
323
306
61
Nov 2017
324
308
61
Dec 2017
330
310
61
Jan 2018
339
312
61
Feb 2018
350
314
63
Mar 2018
354
317
63
Apr 2018
359
320
63
May 2018
366
323
64
Jun 2018
370
325
64
Jul 2018
375
328
64
Aug 2018
382
332
64
Sep 2018
388
337
64
Oct 2018
392
340
64
Nov 2018
399
345
64
Dec 2018
402
349
64
Jan 2019
407
352
64
Feb 2019
411
354
64
Mar 2019
413
360
64
Apr 2019
415
362
64
May 2019
418
368
64
Jun 2019
426
373
64
Jul 2019
434
377
64
Aug 2019
439
381
64
Sep 2019
441
383
64
Oct 2019
443
385
64
Nov 2019
445
388
64
Dec 2019
446
391
64
Jan 2020
451
392
64
Feb 2020
454
394
64
Mar 2020
456
395
64
Apr 2020
458
395
64
May 2020
460
396
64
Jun 2020
465
399
65
Jul 2020
481
433
72
Aug 2020
483
438
75
Sep 2020
484
450
75
Oct 2020
490
452
76
Nov 2020
496
457
77
Dec 2020
502
458
78
Jan 2021
511
464
78
Feb 2021
518
470
78
Mar 2021
524
473
78
Apr 2021
527
479
78
May 2021
532
481
78
Jun 2021
539
483
78
Jul 2021
548
486
78
Aug 2021
557
488
78
Sep 2021
564
489
78
Oct 2021
576
497
78
Nov 2021
584
505
80
Dec 2021
598
508
80
Jan 2022
610
510
80
Feb 2022
623
510
81
Mar 2022
633
511
82
Apr 2022
642
512
83
May 2022
650
513
83
Jun 2022
651
514
83
Jul 2022
669
514
83
Aug 2022
675
517
83
Sep 2022
678
519
83
Oct 2022
686
521
83
Nov 2022
688
523
83
Dec 2022
694
526
84
Jan 2023
701
529
85
Feb 2023
711
532
85
Mar 2023
714
534
85
Apr 2023
717
534
85
May 2023
721
538
85
Jun 2023
723
538
85
Jul 2023
736
538
86
Aug 2023
741
543
87
Sep 2023
756
553
88
Oct 2023
779
557
88
Nov 2023
798
558
88
Dec 2023
809
558
88
Jan 2024
821
559
90
Feb 2024
836
568
91
Mar 2024
850
583
91
Apr 2024
864
587
96
May 2024
867
588
103
Jun 2024
871
588
104
Jul 2024
876
589
105
Aug 2024
880
591
105
Sep 2024
884
593
106
Oct 2024
887
595
106
Nov 2024
891
595
106
Latest update: 21 Nov 2024