|
17 Sep 2010
Status : this preprint was under review for the journal HESS but the revision was not accepted.
Strategies for validating and directions for employing SMOS data, in the Cal-Val project SWEX (3275) for wetlands
W. Marczewski , J. Slominski , E. Slominska , B. Usowicz , J. Usowicz , S. Romanov , O. Maryskevych , J. Nastula , and J. Zawadzki
The paper tries interpreting how the method of SMOS observations realizes managing the problem of large scales and the target heterogeneity by means of employing the polarization angular signature. Land surface target on the Earth is naturally heterogeneous in its continuity of physical and biophysical properties. Soil moisture (SM) retrieval from SMOS data requires using the model CMEM to determine relations between the temperature brightness and water related properties and conditions, which are anchored to the ground by auxiliary data. SM retrieval must start from the conditions at least approaching physical reality. SMOS performs the data fusion in NRT (Nearly Real Time) in a very specific way, what is a new quality added to EO (Earth Observations). The paper demonstrates several effects of employing the SM retrievals from L1C data. Authors explain how they validate few selected test sites in Poland, and come to conclusions on choosing a strategy focused on validating single sites. Finally, they come to an understanding that SM retrieval is an advanced statistical method requiring good referencing to ground based physical conditions in large scales, worth confronting the shallow water content obtained from SMOS to that assessments of the total water content on continental scales, which available from effects of gravitational missions.
Received: 23 Jul 2010 – Discussion started: 17 Sep 2010
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
W. Marczewski , J. Slominski , E. Slominska , B. Usowicz , J. Usowicz , S. Romanov , O. Maryskevych , J. Nastula , and J. Zawadzki
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
W. Marczewski , J. Slominski , E. Slominska , B. Usowicz , J. Usowicz , S. Romanov , O. Maryskevych , J. Nastula , and J. Zawadzki
W. Marczewski , J. Slominski , E. Slominska , B. Usowicz , J. Usowicz , S. Romanov , O. Maryskevych , J. Nastula , and J. Zawadzki
Viewed
Total article views: 2,522 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,962
466
94
2,522
130
136
HTML: 1,962
PDF: 466
XML: 94
Total: 2,522
BibTeX: 130
EndNote: 136
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Feb 2013
5
6
1
12
Mar 2013
1
5
0
6
Apr 2013
1
5
0
6
May 2013
1
10
0
11
Jun 2013
2
7
0
9
Jul 2013
1
5
0
6
Aug 2013
5
0
5
Sep 2013
3
5
0
8
Oct 2013
4
12
0
16
Nov 2013
5
7
0
12
Dec 2013
1
7
1
9
Jan 2014
6
7
0
13
Feb 2014
8
9
3
20
Mar 2014
4
7
2
13
Apr 2014
1
7
1
9
May 2014
5
0
5
Jun 2014
4
0
4
Jul 2014
10
1
11
Aug 2014
1
8
0
9
Sep 2014
1
7
0
8
Oct 2014
11
0
11
Nov 2014
2
6
0
8
Dec 2014
5
0
5
Jan 2015
1
6
0
7
Feb 2015
6
1
0
7
Mar 2015
7
5
1
13
Apr 2015
10
0
10
May 2015
1
0
1
Jun 2015
4
1
0
5
Jul 2015
8
1
0
9
Aug 2015
2
2
0
4
Sep 2015
0
Oct 2015
6
1
0
7
Nov 2015
9
1
0
10
Dec 2015
9
2
0
11
Jan 2016
9
4
0
13
Feb 2016
8
8
1
17
Mar 2016
11
0
11
Apr 2016
8
3
0
11
May 2016
12
1
0
13
Jun 2016
7
1
0
8
Jul 2016
12
4
1
17
Aug 2016
5
5
0
10
Sep 2016
7
0
7
Oct 2016
5
1
6
12
Nov 2016
7
2
9
18
Dec 2016
4
3
0
7
Jan 2017
4
1
0
5
Feb 2017
6
2
1
9
Mar 2017
12
2
0
14
Apr 2017
18
2
0
20
May 2017
17
2
2
21
Jun 2017
27
1
3
31
Jul 2017
15
1
1
17
Aug 2017
8
1
0
9
Sep 2017
6
1
0
7
Oct 2017
3
0
3
Nov 2017
10
1
0
11
Dec 2017
8
2
0
10
Jan 2018
15
4
0
19
Feb 2018
15
1
2
18
Mar 2018
8
2
0
10
Apr 2018
10
3
0
13
May 2018
12
4
0
16
Jun 2018
10
2
0
12
Jul 2018
10
2
0
12
Aug 2018
12
3
0
15
Sep 2018
8
2
0
10
Oct 2018
8
5
0
13
Nov 2018
9
4
0
13
Dec 2018
6
2
0
8
Jan 2019
6
2
0
8
Feb 2019
6
3
0
9
Mar 2019
9
4
0
13
Apr 2019
6
3
0
9
May 2019
7
4
0
11
Jun 2019
10
4
0
14
Jul 2019
6
2
0
8
Aug 2019
8
2
0
10
Sep 2019
9
2
0
11
Oct 2019
6
1
0
7
Nov 2019
8
1
0
9
Dec 2019
3
1
4
Jan 2020
3
0
3
Feb 2020
4
1
0
5
Mar 2020
2
1
0
3
Apr 2020
0
May 2020
5
2
1
8
Jun 2020
11
1
0
12
Jul 2020
22
12
11
45
Aug 2020
6
3
3
12
Sep 2020
4
0
4
Oct 2020
12
6
0
18
Nov 2020
16
2
1
19
Dec 2020
10
3
1
14
Jan 2021
10
2
0
12
Feb 2021
12
3
0
15
Mar 2021
13
1
0
14
Apr 2021
12
4
0
16
May 2021
16
1
0
17
Jun 2021
13
2
0
15
Jul 2021
13
2
0
15
Aug 2021
12
3
1
16
Sep 2021
12
0
12
Oct 2021
20
3
0
23
Nov 2021
13
5
1
19
Dec 2021
18
2
0
20
Jan 2022
22
4
0
26
Feb 2022
18
3
0
21
Mar 2022
10
1
1
12
Apr 2022
14
1
1
16
May 2022
10
2
0
12
Jun 2022
4
0
4
Jul 2022
25
3
0
28
Aug 2022
32
2
0
34
Sep 2022
5
0
5
Oct 2022
12
1
0
13
Nov 2022
8
3
0
11
Dec 2022
8
3
0
11
Jan 2023
15
6
2
23
Feb 2023
11
3
0
14
Mar 2023
12
2
1
15
Apr 2023
4
4
0
8
May 2023
6
3
0
9
Jun 2023
11
4
0
15
Jul 2023
18
2
2
22
Aug 2023
13
4
1
18
Sep 2023
40
3
1
44
Oct 2023
97
1
3
101
Nov 2023
104
3
0
107
Dec 2023
6
1
7
Jan 2024
10
1
0
11
Feb 2024
13
1
2
16
Mar 2024
11
0
11
Apr 2024
9
2
4
15
May 2024
9
6
15
Jun 2024
10
2
1
13
Jul 2024
9
3
2
14
Aug 2024
12
2
0
14
Sep 2024
8
1
0
9
Oct 2024
7
2
0
9
Nov 2024
4
0
4
Dec 2024
6
2
0
8
Jan 2025
18
5
1
24
Feb 2025
13
2
1
16
Mar 2025
17
0
17
Apr 2025
11
6
0
17
May 2025
10
1
2
13
Jun 2025
23
3
1
27
Jul 2025
19
1
0
20
Aug 2025
79
3
2
84
Sep 2025
313
6
1
320
Oct 2025
27
8
0
35
Nov 2025
15
7
2
24
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Feb 2013
5
6
1
Mar 2013
6
11
1
Apr 2013
7
16
1
May 2013
8
26
1
Jun 2013
10
33
1
Jul 2013
11
38
1
Aug 2013
11
43
1
Sep 2013
14
48
1
Oct 2013
18
60
1
Nov 2013
23
67
1
Dec 2013
24
74
2
Jan 2014
30
81
2
Feb 2014
38
90
5
Mar 2014
42
97
7
Apr 2014
43
104
8
May 2014
43
109
8
Jun 2014
43
113
8
Jul 2014
43
123
9
Aug 2014
44
131
9
Sep 2014
45
138
9
Oct 2014
45
149
9
Nov 2014
47
155
9
Dec 2014
47
160
9
Jan 2015
48
166
9
Feb 2015
54
167
9
Mar 2015
61
172
10
Apr 2015
71
172
10
May 2015
71
173
10
Jun 2015
75
174
10
Jul 2015
83
175
10
Aug 2015
85
177
10
Sep 2015
85
177
10
Oct 2015
91
178
10
Nov 2015
100
179
10
Dec 2015
109
181
10
Jan 2016
118
185
10
Feb 2016
126
193
11
Mar 2016
137
193
11
Apr 2016
145
196
11
May 2016
157
197
11
Jun 2016
164
198
11
Jul 2016
176
202
12
Aug 2016
181
207
12
Sep 2016
188
207
12
Oct 2016
193
208
18
Nov 2016
200
210
27
Dec 2016
204
213
27
Jan 2017
208
214
27
Feb 2017
214
216
28
Mar 2017
226
218
28
Apr 2017
244
220
28
May 2017
261
222
30
Jun 2017
288
223
33
Jul 2017
303
224
34
Aug 2017
311
225
34
Sep 2017
317
226
34
Oct 2017
320
226
34
Nov 2017
330
227
34
Dec 2017
338
229
34
Jan 2018
353
233
34
Feb 2018
368
234
36
Mar 2018
376
236
36
Apr 2018
386
239
36
May 2018
398
243
36
Jun 2018
408
245
36
Jul 2018
418
247
36
Aug 2018
430
250
36
Sep 2018
438
252
36
Oct 2018
446
257
36
Nov 2018
455
261
36
Dec 2018
461
263
36
Jan 2019
467
265
36
Feb 2019
473
268
36
Mar 2019
482
272
36
Apr 2019
488
275
36
May 2019
495
279
36
Jun 2019
505
283
36
Jul 2019
511
285
36
Aug 2019
519
287
36
Sep 2019
528
289
36
Oct 2019
534
290
36
Nov 2019
542
291
36
Dec 2019
545
291
37
Jan 2020
548
291
37
Feb 2020
552
292
37
Mar 2020
554
293
37
Apr 2020
554
293
37
May 2020
559
295
38
Jun 2020
570
296
38
Jul 2020
592
308
49
Aug 2020
598
311
52
Sep 2020
602
311
52
Oct 2020
614
317
52
Nov 2020
630
319
53
Dec 2020
640
322
54
Jan 2021
650
324
54
Feb 2021
662
327
54
Mar 2021
675
328
54
Apr 2021
687
332
54
May 2021
703
333
54
Jun 2021
716
335
54
Jul 2021
729
337
54
Aug 2021
741
340
55
Sep 2021
753
340
55
Oct 2021
773
343
55
Nov 2021
786
348
56
Dec 2021
804
350
56
Jan 2022
826
354
56
Feb 2022
844
357
56
Mar 2022
854
358
57
Apr 2022
868
359
58
May 2022
878
361
58
Jun 2022
882
361
58
Jul 2022
907
364
58
Aug 2022
939
366
58
Sep 2022
944
366
58
Oct 2022
956
367
58
Nov 2022
964
370
58
Dec 2022
972
373
58
Jan 2023
987
379
60
Feb 2023
998
382
60
Mar 2023
1,010
384
61
Apr 2023
1,014
388
61
May 2023
1,020
391
61
Jun 2023
1,031
395
61
Jul 2023
1,049
397
63
Aug 2023
1,062
401
64
Sep 2023
1,102
404
65
Oct 2023
1,199
405
68
Nov 2023
1,303
408
68
Dec 2023
1,309
408
69
Jan 2024
1,319
409
69
Feb 2024
1,332
410
71
Mar 2024
1,343
410
71
Apr 2024
1,352
412
75
May 2024
1,361
412
81
Jun 2024
1,371
414
82
Jul 2024
1,380
417
84
Aug 2024
1,392
419
84
Sep 2024
1,400
420
84
Oct 2024
1,407
422
84
Nov 2024
1,411
422
84
Dec 2024
1,417
424
84
Jan 2025
1,435
429
85
Feb 2025
1,448
431
86
Mar 2025
1,465
431
86
Apr 2025
1,476
437
86
May 2025
1,486
438
88
Jun 2025
1,509
441
89
Jul 2025
1,528
442
89
Aug 2025
1,607
445
91
Sep 2025
1,920
451
92
Oct 2025
1,947
459
92
Nov 2025
1,962
466
94
Latest update: 26 Nov 2025